| Peyton Wallace | 2023 | Logan |
| Brooke Schwegler | 2022 | Berne Union |
| Rachel Lee | 2021 | Licking Valley |
| Lindsay Drumm | 2020 & 2019 | Heath |
| Hannah Horsington | 2018 | Lakewood |
| Dana Keller | 2017 | Millersport |
| Melissa Sommers | 2016 | Fairfield Union |
| Allison Zink | 2015 | Johnstown-Monroe |
| Johanna Whetstone | 2014 | Millersport |
| Paige Turner | 2013 | Johnstown-Monroe |
| Briana Keyes | 2012 | Millersport |
| Jordan Johnston | 2011 | Fairfield Union |
| Caitlyn Black | 2010 | Bloom Carroll |
| Kendra Heistand | 2009 | Liberty Union |
| Anna Keyes | 2008 | Logan |
| Jeanette Brown | 2007 | Sheridan |
| Natalie Weil | 2006 | Licking Heights |
| Lindsey Eilbacher | 2005 | Centerburg |
| Noel Sutton | 2004 | Northridge |
| Jennifer Predier | 2003 | Johnstown-Monroe |
| Jackie Sutton | 2002 | Northridge |
| Leslie Althoff | 2001 | Fairfield Union |
| Sarah Bright | 2000 | Johnstown-Monroe |
| Rachel Janel Becker | 1999 | Johnstown-Monroe |
| Brittany Young | 1998 | Lakewood |
| Jessica Lynn Spears | 1997 | Millersport |
| Krista Irmscher | 1996 | Heath |
| Jan Stewart | 1995 | Logan |
| Kimberley Lynn Osborn | 1994 | Heath |
| Nicole Donnini | 1993 | Watkins Memorial |
| Paige Hellyer | 1992 | Johnstown-Monroe |
| Nikki Guisinger | 1991 | Liberty Union |
| Heidi Spears | 1990 | Pickerington |
| Catherine Baird | 1989 | Licking Heights |
| Jennifer Ireton | 1988 | Logan |
| Deanna Eshler | 1987 | Bloom Carroll |
| Theresa Mulroy | 1986 | Fisher Catholic |
| Gina West | 1985 | Pickerington |
| Meredith Wolfe | 1984 | Pickerington |
| Sharon Brigner | 1983 | Amanda |
| Marya Changizi | 1982 | Pickerington |
| Darlene Cannon | 1981 | Pickerington |
| Roxi Erwin | 1980 | Pickerington |
| Jayne Partyka | 1979 | Heath |
| Erin Brookover | 1978 | Millersport |
| Amy Bauer | 1977 | Canal Winchester |
| Carol Jaynes | 1976 | Pickerington |
| Lisa Trocchia | 1975 | Fairfield Union |
| Charlene Ann Berry | 1974 | Johnstown |
| Jill Ruth Waibel | 1973 | Canal Winchester |
| Vicky Jean Wood | 1972 | Lakewood |
| Marilyn Wetherell | 1971 | Pickerington |
| Susan Kay Lawrence | 1970 | Millersport |
| Jane Ann Sherrard* | 1969 | Watkins-Memorial |
| Angie McKinney | 1968 | Heath |
| Linda Williamson | 1967 | Johnstown |
| Rita Barnes | 1966 | Millersport |
| Rosalie Clark | 1965 | Lakewood |
| Sharon Osborn | 1964 | Johnstown |
| Vicki Wooley | 1963 | Pickerington |
| Sandra Lee Ruff | 1962 | Rushville |
| Karen Butt | 1961 | Johnstown |
| Anite Cladenning | 1960 | Amanda |
| Judy Diane Lecompte* | 1959 | Reynoldsburg |
| Jo Ann Sims | 1958 | Baltimore-Basil |
| Sara Ruffner | 1957 | Pleasantville |
| Susan Mitchell | 1956 | Glenford |
| Annis Vaness | 1955 | Hebron |
| Marlene Ridenour | 1954 | Carroll |
| Ann Shreyer | 1953 | Baltimore-Basil |
| Ann Blackstone | 1952 | Thornville |
| Lynn Phalen* | 1951 | Johnstown |
| Carolyn Geiger | 1950 | Millersport |
| Marjorie Householder | 1949 | Thurston |
| Patty Clark* | 1948 | Hebron |
*Deceased